Menu

10 Best Cheesecake Shops in Nashville

A search for cheesecake shops in Nashville can lead to very different dessert experiences. This comparison separates celebration cheesecakes from pastries, ice cream, cookies, cakes, macarons, and café desserts so you can choose based on the treat, timing, and setting you want.

How this guide is ordered

Our look into cheesecake shops around Nashville cut anyone who is not truly specialized, has shaky reviews or makes it tricky to call, email or find hours.

Businesses may pay for promotional services that help them get noticed on this site.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Full Comparison of 10 Cheesecake Bakeries in Nashville

Brightside Bakeshop - East, Nashville#1
What stands out
  • Seasonal and monthly specials alongside layered pastries

Brightside Bakeshop - East

5.0219 reviews
713 Porter Rd, Nashville, TN 37206, United States
Best for
Pastry-focused visits and customers willing to preorder

Brightside Bakeshop - East is a small East Nashville bakery specializing in pastries, especially croissants and other layered puff pastries. The shop also produces monthly or seasonal creations and offers preorders. Its limited hours, small footprint and tendency to sell out quickly make it better suited to planned pastry runs than lingering indoors.

Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge, Nashville#2
What stands out
  • Combines giant cookies with ice cream, shakes, fudge and pie

  • Offers Cuban coffee alongside desserts

Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge

4.8772 reviews
123 2nd Ave N Fl 1, Nashville, TN 37201, United States
Best for
Visitors wanting oversized cookies or generous ice-cream servingsPeople seeking ice cream, fudge or key lime pie downtown

Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge is a compact dessert shop offering cookies, ice cream, shakes, fudge and key lime pie. Its large cookies and generous scoops suit visitors looking for substantial treats, while the menu also includes Cuban coffee. The shop is a convenient stop for dessert while visiting downtown Nashville.

SusieCakes - Nashville#3
What stands out
  • Offers custom layer cakes alongside from-scratch cookies and pies

  • Carries individual cake slices and cupcakes for walk-in visits

SusieCakes - Nashville

4.8426 reviews
2177 Green Hills Village Dr, Nashville, TN 37215, United States
Best for
Celebrations requiring custom layer cakesWalk-in dessert runs for cake slices, cookies or cupcakesShoppers seeking a gluten-free treat

SusieCakes – Nashville is a cake shop and bakery offering from-scratch desserts, including cookies, pies and custom layer cakes. The shop also carries cake slices and cupcakes, making it suitable for both walk-in treats and celebrations. Its selection includes gluten-free treats, and customers can sample some cakes when available.

TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles, Nashville#4
What stands out
  • Cheesecakes are presented as both a dessert and a celebration centerpiece

  • The business has handled a rush order with on-time delivery

TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles

4.936 reviews
Best for
Celebrations needing a custom cheesecakeCustomers seeking distinctive flavors such as red moscato or turtleLast-minute orders when delivery is arranged

TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles is a dessert shop specializing in cheesecakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries and other celebrations. Customers can choose flavors such as red moscato, strawberry and turtle, with presentation treated as carefully as flavor and texture. The business is also suited to rush orders, with one account describing clear communication and on-time delivery for a last-minute request.

The Baked Bear, Nashville#5
What stands out
  • Warmed cookie-and-ice-cream sandwiches

  • Polar-bear-den-inspired interior

The Baked Bear

4.7924 reviews
1809 Division St, Nashville, TN 37203, United States
Best for
Ice-cream sandwiches and richly flavored baked dessertsGroups wanting individual cookies, ice cream or combined desserts

The Baked Bear is a Nashville dessert restaurant centered on cookies, brownies and ice cream. Visitors can order individual cookies or ice cream, or combine them into warmed cookie-and-ice-cream sandwiches. Its polar-bear-den interior adds a playful setting, while the menu offers plenty of cookie and ice-cream combinations for an indulgent dessert stop.

Shugga Hi Bakery & Cafe, Nashville#6
What stands out
  • Combines bakery and café fare with live jazz

  • Menu spans breakfast and lunch, including biscuits, fried chicken, and fish and grits

Shugga Hi Bakery & Cafe

4.7881 reviews
1000 Dickerson Pike, Nashville, TN 37207, United States
Best for
Breakfast or brunch with Southern comfort foodDiners seeking made-from-scratch dishes and generous portionsVisitors who enjoy live music with a meal

Shugga Hi Bakery & Cafe is a Nashville bakery and café serving Southern-inspired breakfast, brunch, lunch, biscuits, fried chicken, fish and grits, and other made-from-scratch dishes. It suits diners looking for generous comfort food in a cozy setting, with live jazz adding an evening-and-meal component. The café also presents a community-minded identity tied to feeding people in need.

Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South, Nashville#7
What stands out
  • Specializes in 100-layer donuts with a croissant-like texture

  • Includes a fenced toddler soft-play area outdoors

  • Offers some gluten-free options

Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South

4.63,011 reviews
1110 Caruthers Ave, Nashville, TN 37204, United States
Best for
Visitors seeking distinctive layered donutsFamilies wanting outdoor space and toddler play featuresGuests choosing among donuts, pastries, cookies and drinks

Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South is a Nashville counter-serve family bakery known for 100-layer donuts and classic pastries. The signature donuts have a layered, croissant-like texture, with flavors ranging from maple and cream cheese to filled varieties. The shop also offers cookies, tea, iced coffee and some gluten-free options, plus outdoor seating and a fenced toddler soft-play area.

Café Intermezzo - Nashville#8
What stands out
  • The coffee menu is extensive and served in carafes with several small cups

  • The atmosphere includes European décor and classic piano music

Café Intermezzo - Nashville

4.61,204 reviews
205 Demonbreun Street, 2nd Ave S, Nashville, TN 37201, United States
Best for
Diners seeking a relaxed European-style settingGuests looking for coffee, crêpes, pastries, or a lighter meal

Café Intermezzo - Nashville is a European-style coffeehouse and restaurant serving an extensive beverage selection, pastries, crêpes, and sandwiches. The setting pairs European-inspired décor with gentle classic piano music, while the menu supports anything from coffee and pastries to dishes such as Chicken Florentine Crêpe, omelets, Benedicts, salads, and sandwiches. It suits relaxed meals, shareable coffee, and dessert stops.

Le Macaron Nashville#9
What stands out
  • French macarons offered alongside gelato and chocolates

  • Seasonal flavors and a visually distinctive shop

Le Macaron Nashville

4.5522 reviews
5006 Broadway, Nashville, TN 37203, United States
Best for
People seeking French macarons and varied sweetsA casual dessert stop with outdoor-front seating

Le Macaron Nashville is a pastry shop specializing in French macarons alongside chocolates, gelato and other sweet treats. It suits visitors looking for a small dessert stop in a cute, decorated setting, with flavors such as rose, salted caramel and seasonal specialties represented in the selection. Seating out front provides a place to enjoy sweets on site.

Milk & Honey Gulch, Nashville#10
What stands out
  • Housemade gelati and baked goods

  • Scratch kitchen with food made in-house

Milk & Honey Gulch

4.43,859 reviews
214 11th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37203, United States
Best for
Scratch-made brunch and baked goodsCoffee, pastries and grab-and-go visits

Milk & Honey Gulch is a brunch restaurant and coffee shop offering housemade gelati, baked goods and light fare. Its scratch kitchen makes food in-house, with fresh biscuits, pop tarts and other baked items among the offerings described. The business suits diners who enjoy brunch, coffee and a welcoming atmosphere, but limited seating can mean a wait.

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviewsBest for
#1Brightside Bakeshop - East 5.0219Pastry-focused visits and customers willing to preorder
#2Mattheessen's - Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge 4.8772Visitors wanting oversized cookies or generous ice-cream servings
#3SusieCakes - Nashville 4.8426Celebrations requiring custom layer cakes
#4TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles 4.936Celebrations needing a custom cheesecake
#5The Baked Bear 4.7924Ice-cream sandwiches and richly flavored baked desserts
#6Shugga Hi Bakery & Cafe 4.7881Breakfast or brunch with Southern comfort food
#7Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South 4.63,011Visitors seeking distinctive layered donuts
#8Café Intermezzo - Nashville 4.61,204Diners seeking a relaxed European-style setting
#9Le Macaron Nashville 4.5522People seeking French macarons and varied sweets
#10Milk & Honey Gulch 4.43,859Scratch-made brunch and baked goods

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Compare Nashville dessert shops by area

The geographic view is intended to show how dessert options compare across the Nashville search area. The supplied information identifies some locations or areas, such as downtown, East Nashville, 12th South, the Gulch, and Goodlettsville, but does not provide a complete neighborhood guide.

Dessert styles represented in this Nashville comparison

  • Custom celebration cheesecakesTJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles specializes in cheesecakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations, with flavors including red moscato, strawberry, and turtle.
  • Cookies and ice creamMattheessen’s combines large cookies with ice cream, shakes, fudge, key lime pie, and Cuban coffee; The Baked Bear offers warmed cookie-and-ice-cream sandwiches.
  • Layer cakes and walk-in slicesSusieCakes – Nashville offers custom layer cakes as well as slices, cupcakes, cookies, pies, and some gluten-free treats.
  • Layered pastries and donutsBrightside Bakeshop - East focuses on croissants and layered pastries, while Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South is known for 100-layer donuts.
  • Macarons and French-style sweetsLe Macaron Nashville offers French macarons alongside chocolates, gelato, and other sweets.
  • Café desserts and baked goodsCafé Intermezzo, Milk & Honey Gulch, and Shugga Hi Bakery & Cafe pair pastries or baked goods with coffee, brunch, or full meals.

How to narrow down Nashville cheesecake-shop choices

  1. Match the format to the occasionFor a centerpiece, consider TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles or SusieCakes; for an individual treat, look at slices, cookies, macarons, or ice cream.
  2. Plan around availabilityBrightside Bakeshop - East has limited hours and may sell out, while SusieCakes samples can vary by day.
  3. Consider portion sizeMattheessen’s describes large cookies and generous scoops, and Five Daughters notes that filled donuts can be very sweet.
  4. Decide whether seating mattersBrightside has no indoor tables, while Le Macaron offers front seating and several cafés provide a sit-down setting.
  5. Check special dietary needsSusieCakes and Five Daughters Bakery document some gluten-free options; confirm current availability before ordering.

Frequently asked questions

Which Nashville option is most focused on custom cheesecake?

TJ’s Cheesecake Chronicles specializes in cheesecakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations.

Can I buy individual desserts rather than a whole cake?

Yes. SusieCakes offers cake slices and cupcakes, while the listed dessert shops also include individual cookies, ice cream, macarons, pastries, and other sweets.

Which options offer gluten-free treats?

SusieCakes documents gluten-free treats, and Five Daughters Bakery | 12th South documents some gluten-free options.

Which shop suits a planned pastry run?

Brightside Bakeshop - East is described as better for planned pastry visits because it has limited hours and can sell out quickly.

Related guides